Govt. policy versus freedom of opinion

15 February 2019, 12:00AM

The Government’s decision to sack the Nofoali’i village mayor over his comments against the Government’s land law reforms has raised a rather interesting question. Can the Government sack village mayors who are appointed by the villages? What’s more, where does this leave Government employees when it comes to the question of freedom and rights? Talaia Mika and Misiona Simo discussed the issue with members of the public and these are their views:

Valma Tonu’u, 34, Fugalei

The Government is our government. But we also have the right to say what we think is right even if it means it’s against them. We voted for them to be our leaders and again, we have every right to say whatever we think is right. I think the Government should listen to the people sometimes.


Anesone Elama, 43, Saleimoa

I don’t take sides in these kinds of cases. I think, however, that whatever the Government thinks is best for the country, people should listen. People who disagree have their own rights but we should all try and agree with the Government so we can avoid these things.


Toalua Tauavae, 42, Siusega

The government does not have the right to anyone’s rights because that’s their right. I don’t care so much about their rules but I care more about people’s freedom. I don’t support the idea they can just sack anyone they don’t like. I think people should have the freedom to say what they want. This is a free country.


Easter Nun Yan, 20, Vaoala

This is a matter of right versus policy. I don’t think it’s fair for the Government to have such a policy. I mean it’s our rights as citizens to go against them for something we think is not right. They are not perfect themselves. Whether people work for the Government or not, they have a right as individual and they should be encouraged to use that right.


Iulio Ioane, 46, Salepoua’e

Personally, it’s our government and we own the government. When it comes to the Prime Minister, we also voted for him to be up there. It’s not just his country it’s everyone’s country. The Government has to take the advice and listen to the people. A lot of people nowadays are afraid to share their opinions which is sad. The Government should encourage a free and fair discussion of issues.


Fa’aa’e Faletaoga, 35, Saina

With regards to the Nofoalii case, I take my hat off to the village mayor. He cannot support the Government when he sees that a government law is hurting his people. Is it right to agree with the Government’s policies and leave their lands that they see as treasures to him and his village people? I think the Government should encourage people to be free and speak their minds. There should not be a law that allows the Government to fire people when they don’t toe the line.


Meatuai Sefo, 35, Vaitele

Samoa is an independent country; our people should be free. It’s not like I want people to criticize the government or what because I also don’t want people to go against our government because they’re our representatives. But my concern is that people should have the freedom of choice and opinion. I also think the Government should consult the villages about the decision to sack a village mayor.


Queenmary Maia’i, 21, Moamoa

If I were to work for the Government as the Mayor for my village, I won’t ever hide anything that I think is right just because I’m not allowed to go against the Government. If something needs improvement, I will go ahead and tell the Government. It’s more like hiding the truth in criminal cases and not revealing them.

15 February 2019, 12:00AM
Samoa Observer

Upgrade to Premium

Subscribe to
Samoa Observer Online

Enjoy unlimited access to all our articles on any device + free trial to e-Edition. You can cancel anytime.